Diagnosing Problems With A Nonprofit Funnel

In the nonprofit world, a clean and functioning funnel is essential. It’s how you guide a prospect all the way from their first interaction with you to an eventual action. But if you aren’t getting the results you want? This is when correctly diagnosing problems with a nonprofit funnel is so important.  

In our latest post, we are showing you how to do just that. This includes what a nonprofit funnel is, the most common problems, and how to fix them.

What Is A Nonprofit Funnel? 

As we have written before, a nonprofit funnel is the path that someone takes from awareness to action. It’s every interaction they have with your brand between where they are now, and where you want them to be. What that end action is for nonprofits? Typically choosing to donate, volunteer, become a member, or support a campaign. 

As for the typical stages of a nonprofit funnel? Here is a basic version to keep in mind while reading this post: 

• Awareness: Your audience first learns about your nonprofit.
• Engagement: They interact with any content you might have and learn more about your organizational mission.
• Consideration: They start to consider donating and likely look into your impact and credibility.
• Conversion / Donation: They actually donate to your cause, regardless of the amount.
• Retention: After donating, you work to keep them engaged and primed to potentially donate again in the future.

Even if you never intentionally set one up, odds are you already have some version of a funnel in place at your nonprofit. But here’s the key thing: these stages need to be measurable. This is how you can spot problems with your funnel, and fix them if they do occur. 

Common Problems With A Nonprofit Funnel

It’s one thing to talk about “problems with your funnel.” That’s quite vague. It’s an entirely different thing to put a name to them. 

Here are the most common problems that you will experience with a nonprofit funnel:

• Weak lead generation: you aren’t bringing in enough leads. 
• Poorly defined audience segments: you treat each person in your audience more or less the same, and don’t adjust your messaging for different groups.
• Inconsistent nurturing: once somebody does enter your funnel, there are no systems in place to nurture them and communication drops off.
• Unclear calls-to-action: supporters aren’t clear what to do next because your CTA’s are buried or vague. 
• No funnel metrics: your team either doesn’t track funnel performance, or doesn’t know how to improve what you do track.

While these are just five problems with nonprofit funnels, they give you an idea of what you should be on the lookout for. Let’s now explore a system for fixing them.

Diagnosing Problems With A Nonprofit Funnel

Step 1: Map Out Your Funnel

Before you can fix a funnel, you need to see it clearly. Start by mapping out:

• The entry points (how people find your organization)
• The conversion points (the actions you want them to take)
• The pathways in between (your emails, content you publish, etc.)

Get specific here so you can visualize the entire journey. This first step is crucial. If you want to diagnose your funnel, you first need to understand it.

Step 2: Check the Numbers

Time to pull your metrics. Look at how many people are going through each stage, as well as the actions they are taking.

Common funnel metrics include:

• Website traffic (awareness)
• Email signups or social follows (engagement)
• Click-through rates or event RSVPs (consideration)
• Donation amount or signup rate (conversion)
• Repeat engagement or second donations (retention)

Be on the lookout here for any kind of steep dropoff. This is your first clue that something needs to be fixed. 

If you aren’t numbers savvy, this second step can be confusing. We recommend first learning about the most important funnel metrics and how to measure them.

Step 3: Identify The Problem

Step 3 is all about why. We already covered five of the most common problems with nonprofit funnels. Let’s look at specific solutions.

Problem: weak lead generation

• Potential solution: make your value proposition clear, and create something of high value that people get when they become a lead

Problem: poorly defined audience segments

• Potential solution: look at your audience as a collection of “mini audience” with different needs and desires, and set up a segmentation system to reflect that

Problem: inconsistent nurturing

• Potential solution: set up things like an email welcome sequence and a post-donation follow-up automation so you are in constant contact with the people that matter most

Problem: unclear calls-to-action

• Potential solution: design all your CTA’s with two standards: easy to understand, and easy to find 

Problem: no funnel metrics

• Potential solution: data performance marketing more seriously and hire outside help if your team doesn’t currently possess the expertise

Step 4: Run Small Tests

At this point you have diagnosed the problem with your nonprofit funnel. Now it’s time to test things out. The goal here is not to try to overhaul everything at once. A/B testing is all about making tweaks so you can pinpoint what works – and what doesn’t. 

Here are a few ideas for you:

• A/B test email subject lines or landing page copy
• Add a “next step” CTA after blog posts or events
• Rework your onboarding emails for new subscribers
• Use surveys to learn why people don’t convert

Think of it like triage: fix the biggest leaks first, then refine as you go.

Step 5: Zoom Out

Lastly, we recommend a mindset shift. A good funnel is important, sure. But most essential is the strategy behind it.

It’s important to remember that a funnel is part of the wider marketing system that you have set up. It can only do so much. Even the best funnel can’t convert the wrong audience.

Here are a few questions to ask your team: 

• Are we attracting the right people?
• Is the action we’re asking for aligned with their needs or motivations?
• Are we building trust before asking for commitment?

Remember this: funnels aren’t just pipelines. They’re relationships. If that relationship feels rushed, impersonal, or one-sided, your funnel is going to underperform.

…

Are you an enterprise, nonprofit or small business looking for help on your website? Give us a shout! We provide a free consultation. Email us at [email protected] or call us at (718) 855-1919!