Donor Retention At Nonprofits

How To Improve Donor Retention At Your Nonprofit

Donor retention is one of the most important topics for nonprofits. Getting new donations is great; even better is having donors stick around.

Today we are diving into the topic of donor retention. This includes not only a few reasons for why it’s so important, but how you can improve donor retention at your own organization.

Why Donor Retention Is Important For Nonprofits

Let’s first discuss why donor retention is so crucial for nonprofits. The answer might seem obvious, but there are a few key points you need to keep in mind. Let’s check out some of them below.

Sustainability Over The Long Term

Donor retention is the bedrock of financial sustainability for nonprofits. A loyal donor base provides a steady and predictable source of funding. This is essential for any nonprofit with big goals. Get your donor retention right, and you aren’t just sustainable, but can tackle ambitious projects (and make a bigger difference) as well.

Reduced Costs

Long-term success for a nonprofit isn’t just about bringing in more funds – you also need to reduce costs where you can. It’s been proven that acquiring new donors is often more expensive than retaining existing ones. The way you prevent this? Donor retention. By fostering lasting relationships over time, nonprofits minimize the resources spent on constant outreach and acquisition.

Higher Impact

While we just mentioned it, it’s worth repeating: good donor retention allows you to have a bigger impact.  Long-term donors are more likely to deepen their engagement. This can lead to increased contributions over time and a heightened impact on your nonprofit’s mission.

Advocacy And Ambassadorship

Good donor retention is usually a knock-on effect of satisfied donors. After all, if your organization is untrustworthy (or not so effective with the donations you do receive) it’s unlikely that somebody will continue to give to you. But if you do? One of the expected effects is also increased advocacy: people talking about your cause and promoting what you do. Good donor retention, over time, essentially creates free marketing.

Now that we know why donor retention is so important, let’s cover how you make it happen.

5 Ways To Improve Donor Retention

1) Give Regular Updates

People want to know what’s going on with your nonprofit. This is especially true if they are choosing to donate their money to your cause. This is where communication comes in. Keep donors informed about your organization’s activities, achievements, and challenges.

You can do this through regular newsletters, impact reports, and general updates. This not only creates a sense of transparency and involvement, but humanizes your organization. The result? More engagement, and higher retention.

2) Express Gratitude

No use communicating with your audience if you don’t thank them! Let’s be honest – if you are a nonprofit, your donors are the reason you’re able to do what you do. It’s only through their giving that you can stay up and running. With that in mind, donor retention requires sincere appreciation.

How you do this, of course, is very much up to you. Personalized thank-you notes are always appreciated, but even imperfect efforts can go a long way. The purpose here is to make them feel valued, which is an essential step in retaining them as a donor. 

3) Showcase Impact

Even if a donor knows that you appreciate them, it’s still necessary to show them what their money is achieving. This is where a lot of nonprofit organizations fall short. They do well at telling people what their donation is going towards – but fail at actually showing them.

As for how you do this? Consider success stories, testimonials, and real-world examples. This is how you showcase how their support is making a difference, and how you encourage them to keep giving.

4) Establish A Loyalty Program

Recurring revenue is the name of the game for businesses. It’s much the same for nonprofits. The fact is, any donation is great. Any amount of money that people decide to give is valuable, and should be treated (and communicated) as such. Still, the real goal is to get recurring donations. This is where donor retention becomes especially important.

One of the best strategies is by establishing a loyalty program. This gives donors a reward for their help, which acts as an incentive for their continued support. The reward can be anything. Still, it should be especially valuable for your audience. This might involve special recognition, exclusive content, or even early access to certain events.

5) Create A Community

Community building as a nonprofit is tricky. It requires a bit of effort to get started and continued effort to maintain. Plus, for a community to last over the long term, you need a group of people with shared interest. Clearly, the challenges are numerous – but the potential upside is huge.

If you get the community aspect of your nonprofit right, higher donor retention is a natural result. You just need to be sure you approach it with the right strategy. Be sure to educate yourself on community building to get started on the right foot.

Are you an enterprise, nonprofit or small business looking for help on your website? Give us a shout! We provide a free consultation. Email us at or call us at (718) 855-1919!

Back to blog